Static Stretching. You either love it or hate it.
I apologize in advance for using the clickbait title, but I firmly believe this article may change your mind on a common practice you have been doing for years before running, biking, and other endurance activities.
For decades you’ve been told this practice prevents injuries, decreases muscle soreness, and makes you go faster. The practice I’m referring to is STRETCHING.
More specifically, the grab and hold method of stretching known as static stretching. I’m sure you are all familiar with the drill. You warm up for 5-10 minutes, find a nice grassy spot under a tree, and pull and yank on your muscles to your heart's content.
Now comes the part that may be a little hard to swallow for some. Brace yourself…performing static stretching before endurance exercise is a complete waste of time.
You’ll get no argument from me that it will make you more flexible but there is not one piece of scientific evidence showing that static stretching helps you stay injury free, lessens muscle soreness, or helps you perform better.
Actually, it’s quite the opposite. Multiple studies have shown that static stretching can DECREASE endurance performance when performed before a workout or race. Why is this?
Part of the reason endurance performance decreases after static stretching is that it relaxes the muscles and associated tendons
This relaxation reduces the stretch response. Because a muscle and its tendons store energy when being rapidly stretched (often called a countermovement), reducing this stretch response weakens the endurance athlete.
During a run, the relaxation of the muscle and tendons may similarly affect the phase in which you push off of the ground. As your foot makes contact with the ground, it stores energy, which it then uses to drive you into the air. This is why at fast speeds, running is more efficient than walking.
The primary difference in energy output when running is in ground contact time.
In all sports that involve running, it’s well known that contact time with the ground limits performance. If the ability to push off the ground is reduced by stretching, then it stands to reason that static stretching might also hinder endurance performance, specifically by decreasing running economy.
Essentially, running after static stretching will require more energy
At this point, you may think I am full of it and feeding you a bunch of poppycock so let’s see what the science has to say.
In the first study, the researchers (one who is the co-founder of EndurElite) noted that running economy is likely affected by static stretching, but only at the start of endurance exercise, after which the body acclimates and economy improves.
They looked at performance over a short run of one mile. The mile test was at a five percent uphill grade, which increased the strength component required to maintain a low contact time.
The researchers measured more than just the time it took to complete the mile. If there was a difference in performance, they wanted to know why. So they also looked at ground contact time and also muscle activation via electromyography (EMG).
When the runners stretched, they were indeed slower at running the mile by a full thirteen seconds, which is quite a long time in a one-mile run.
The researchers found that muscle activity and ground contact both increased after stretching, indicating it took more effort to complete the run which resulted in the slower times.
The researchers did find that flexibility was greater after stretching, which came as no surprise.
This study demonstrated that static stretching does, in fact, reduce endurance performance, at least at the beginning of a run.
In a second study, researchers at the University of Milan argued that the performance-damping effects of stretching may be more obvious in endurance cycling than in running.
The reason is that type II muscle fibers (a.k.a. fast twitch) are affected more than type I muscle fibers (slow twitch) by stretching. When you’re running at below-threshold paces, your leg muscles are only applying about 20% of their maximal force, so they can rely mainly on type I fibers.
Cycling, on the other hand, requires a greater proportion of maximal force: about 60% of max force at 85% VO2max, according to the paper.
As a result, cyclists recruit a higher proportion of type II fibers, and are thus more vulnerable to stretching-induced weakness
That’s all fine in theory — but what do the experiments say? The researchers did a series of tests of VO2max, mechanical efficiency, time to exhaustion (with the power set at 85% of power at VO2max, so that exhaustion took about 30 minutes), and so on.
Here are the efficiency results, with open circles corresponding to no stretching and closed circles corresponding to 30-minute pre-exercise stretching routine:
On average, efficiency was about 4% lower after stretching. Time to exhaustion was decreased by 26% after stretching (22:57 vs. 31:12).
Sorry to piss in your cheerios this Wednesday morning but I’ll say it again, static stretching before endurance exercise is a complete waste of time and can decrease performance.
The studies above are only two examples of the massive amount of research that exists on the topic.
By now you're probably wondering what you should do instead of stretching to make sure you are adequately warmed up before a workout or race. The solution is quit simple....dynamic stretching!
I’ll admit that static stretching does have a place in sports like gymnastics and underwater basket weaving where being more flexible is advantageous.
It may also help in individual’s who lack proper mobility. But that’s about it. So save 15 minutes of your day by not stretching before your next workout or race and use that time to grab a beer afterward. It’s probably better for you.
Lowery, R. P., Joy, J. M., Brown, L. E., de Souza, E. O., Wistocki, D. R., Davis, G. S., ... & Wilson, J. M. (2014). Effects of static stretching on 1-mile uphill run performance. The Journal of Strength & Conditioning Research, 28(1), 161-167.
Esposito, F., Ce, E., & Limonta, E. (2012). Cycling efficiency and time to exhaustion are reduced after acute passive stretching administration. Scandinavian journal of medicine & science in sports, 22(6), 737-745.